Rearing
and Maintenance of the Bear cub |
||
Ownership:
Administration of the questionnaire revealed that 66% of the Kalandars
presently dancing bears had actually reared it themselves from a cub.
30% had acquired semi-trained juvenile bears or already trained adults
from fellow Kalandars, who sell at times of domestic crisis but usually
always to a fellow Kalandar or through a middleman who is again a Kalandar.
Only 4% on the questionnaire mentioned that they had sold a bear to a
travelling circus because of its old age or to private collectors who
wanted to keep it as a “pet”. The Kalandar felt it was optimal
the bear cub be raised, fed, trained and danced by the owner himself,
specially during the initial training period of 6 months to a year; the
age of the cub being between 4 to 6 months when the training begins. However
it is often not possible for the same member of the family to take the
bear out for dancing / earning and several family members participated
in dancing and walking the bear after the initial training period was
over. Village elders are often asked to help in breaking in the cub. At
BV4, BV7 and BV8, three village elders who acted as trainers were interviewed.
Only one of them still danced a bear. The other two had retired and helped
train the cubs brought to their village. They received payment in cash
or kind from the fellow Kalandar for this service. The investigators found
a direct relationship between the Kalandar’s confidence in handling
his bear and the age at which the bear cub had been acquired. If the Kalandar
had singlehandedly raised the cub as we found to be the case at one of
the largest settlements, BV13, the bear does not suffer the same degree
of abuse through the rest of its life. The reasons are simple: the Kalandar
does not then tie him down with a very short rope, or pull with unnecessary
force on the dancing rope nor does he need intimidation with the stick
or hitting with an iron chain; nor does he use hunger as a method of control
throughout the bear’s life. Being familiar with the cub’s
habits from the beginning, the family and the bear handler develop a better
working relationship. It is rare for a Kalandar to own more than one adult
bear whether he intends to dance it or sell it a little later. Eight families
were encountered that owned a cub and an adult or a juvenile and an adult;
and only one family in the entire survey period owned four adult bears.
In two cases a Kalandar took the bear for dancing in order to pay off
a debt he owed the actual owner of the bear. We gathered this can happen
quite often in the Kalandar community not because the actual bear owner
is too rich and is “hiring” someone to dance his bear but
because one kalandar owes the other money (borrowed during a domestic
emergency) and this is one way the debt can be paid off. |
||
Maintenance and feeding: The bear cub usually reaches the village
traumatised and dehydrated. Initially the cub is kept close to its owner
in a basket or under a coop and brought out only for feeding. After a
couple of weeks it is tied by a rope, to a bamboo pole, close to other
cubs, and fed a wheat gruel along with its milk. The Kalandar claims to
add jaggery to this feed to fatten the cub and win its confidence. It
takes fifteen to twenty days the Kalandar claims for the new cubs to accept
this relationship and begin eating well. The mortality rate can be high
at this stage. During one of visits the investigators released the cubs
from the bamboo posts to observe their behaviour. They were playful and
didn’t stray far from where they were tied. Their play consisted
of a variety of vocalisations as they indulged in mock attacks and wrestled
with each other. But the Kalandars evinced no interest in leaving the
cubs free to exercise themselves and to explore their surroundings. Considering
the cub in the wild accompanies his mother and explores his world around
this age, this continuous tethering of cubs by a short rope throughout
the day and night is a cruelty difficult to evaluate or quantify. So too
they are deprived of all the warmth, touch and company of an adult (mother)
bear and it is no wonder the cubs are continuously mewling / whining and
tugging at their ropes; or in desperation they go up and down the bamboo
poles to which they find themselves tethered. They are left free only
when they are opened for their feed. The Kalandar claims feeding a cub
costs between Rs 20 to Rs 30 per day and the costs rise steadily till
the adult bear costs them between Rs75 and Rs 110 per day. Some Kalandars
claim to feed Chana Ata, i.e. powdered gram with the milk to the cub,
yet others claim to add soft fruits, but the investigators found no signs
of this in any of the villages visited. By and large in North India milk
and wheat porridge is fed to the cub; and in the South, Ragi porridge
and milk is fed till the cub is about six months of age. After six months
of age the cub is fed twice a day, with large Rotis (baked breads made
out of wheat flour) mixed in milk ,in North India. In South India they
are fed steamed Ragi balls and milk twice a day. Twice a year when the
season changes from hot to cold and cold to hot, the bear is fed several
kilos of Ghee (clarified fat) about _ a kilo each morning for 7-8 days,
which the Kalandar claims “deworms” it, “cleans its
stomach” and prepares it for the change of season. To prepare the
bear for the colder months in the North, similarly _ kg of jaggery (molasses)
is fed to the bear each day, for about 8-10 days. This the Kalandar claims
builds up the bears’ resistance to infections, probably by building
up the fatty deposits. Although the Kalandars are well aware of the natural
diet of the bear there is no attempt at feeding the bears in a more balanced
fashion; the Kalandar logic being the animal is no longer “wild”
and has to be given a “human” diet, The heaviest concentrations
of dancing bears were in BV7 and BV13. Here the bears on an average recorded
longer life spans; when physically examined they had glossier coats and
were larger in size and heavier. |
||
Significantly both the villages had large tracts of open space with plenty
of trees and scrubby undergrowth with large termite mounds and ant hills
and the bears had access to this. In these villages the bears were kept
on long twenty feet ropes that allowed them to grub about in the soil
for their favourite food. This addition to their diet significantly improved
their health. Secondly these bear men were closer to the highways and
could attract a large tourist trade; or earn by entertaining at hotels
where a programme would be arranged for eg. at festivals. This was another
factor which contributed to their better health, as undue stress while
walking long distances was avoided. Thirdly most of the bears in these
two villages had been reared as cubs by the same owner who was still dancing
them or a member of the immediate family was handling them. The bears
had not suffered frequent changes of owners / handlers. All these factors
contributed to their better health and maintenance and the owners enjoyed
a closer relationship with their animals. By and large the bears were
groomed meticulously by the Kalandars if the expected route to be taken
was one frequented by foreign tourists or they had been given a contract
by hotel proprietors to sit at fixed spots for their guests. Thus the
bears of BV4, BV7 and BV8 and BV11 were even shampooed and combed, as
tourists enjoyed physically stroking and handling the bears. When on the
road or dancing before rural and small town Indian audiences the bears
were often coated in mud and suffered cuts on their foot pads and suffered
an unexplained eye discharge. The bears also walked longer distances,
their feeding was often disrupted and rest timings became irregular and
they were treated more roughly as rural audiences often teased and provoked
the animal. So the Kalandar is extra vigilant to ensure that no member
of the public gets scratched or attacked by his bear and he consequently
treats his bear more abusively. The staking of the bears when at rest
varied. In 70% of the cases observed, the rope taken through the nose
was attached to a chain/rope which could be as short as three or four
feet. The position is one of acute discomfort and the bear cannot turn
or stand up to sharpen its claws on a tree or lie at full length. In about
80% of the cases observed the bear had dug a shallow depression and rain
water had filled it up, so that the bear stood defensively hunched up
near its stake for long periods of time or curled up on the soggy ground
resigned to its fate. Although the Kalandar claimed to change the bear’s
resting site thrice a day, we rarely found them that concerned. In some
villages the bears are surrounded by cut branches of the thorny kikar
tree which protects it from dogs and acts as camouflage from the idle,
curious passerby. |
||
Nose
Piercing: The cub suffers trauma when it is pushed and pulled
by the children of the village in an attempt to break it in and get it
used to being handled by men. However its first ordeal by pain is when
the nose is pierced and a thick rope inserted through the cheek tissue
and removed from its mouth. This is the first nose piercing when the rope
and needle is pulled through the top of the cheek and out through the
|
||
mouth.
A second nose piercing is done after another four months when the cub’s
snout is larger and the cartilage of the upper palate is stronger to withstand
a thicker rope. This time the rope is pulled out through either the right
or left nostril. Often the bear paws itself repeatedly or tugs at the
rope in a bid to escape the pain and tears the inflamed tissues. In such
cases the kalandar repeats the nose piercing at another site on the snout.
It is quite common to see several scars on the snouts of the adult / juvenile
bears. Although the Kalandars in a few villages claimed to go to a veterinarian
for the nose piercings and insisted local anesthesia was used and painkillers
given after, this was a tutored reply given at the start of the investigation.
In all the questionnaires administered after the investigators had won
their trust, 96% replied the bear cub’s nose was pierced by a village
elder or an experienced owner in the village itself, with a large iron
needle about 6.5 inches in length. It was only in the second year of investigations
that the researchers could witness the first nose piercing. The crude
iron needle such as is used to sew mattresses and sackcloth, is heated
in a coal fire and plunged in with a group of men holding the squealing
cub tight. The site of the nose piercing was invariably infected in all
the 17 cases we observed when the questionnaire was being administered.
All cubs observed since then have also been found to have infected pus
filled nose piercings with the muzzle swollen and distorted, sometimes
up to four months after the first piercing. The cub would then have to
suffer a second nose piercing before the first was healed, compounding
his agony. It is significant that this is the optimal training period
as the cub will walk and rear up on its hind legs mainly because of the
agony it suffers when the rope is tugged. No medication was being applied
to the muzzle till the investigators donated antibiotic ointments and
fly-repelling creams. The Kalandar puts “Sarsoo oil” to ease
the pain and soften the tissues but it is a sweet oil and attracts flies.
Although simple Ayurvedic indigenous ointments are available and can prevent
infection, the Kalandar does not use this information, preferring to do
what his forefathers always did. In Karnataka a Brass ring was put into
the nose of the bear and then a chain or a rope attached. This practice
was only noticed in the bears examined in the South. If the measurement
of the muzzle was done carelessly often the snout of the bear remained
compressed and distorted as the ring was smaller than needed. Secondly
a very cruel mode of control was to insert the bearman’s stick into
the ring and twist it a little, thereby causing the animal a great deal
of pain; thirdly more than one rope can be attached to the brass ring,
if the bear is of bad temperament and facilitate control of the bear.
Of the 97 adult bears the investigators examined, about 40% still had
their original nose hole.The others bore scars to show torn cartilage
and large cuts, distorted muzzles, several openings in the nose indicating
re-piercing. The trainers explained that a recalcitrant or ill tempered
adult bear would have to be re-pierced in a bid to tame him with pain
and control him. Others explained that simply with age and wear and tear,
it becomes necessary to redo the holes. Only one percent of the interviewed
Kalandars were willing to forego the nose piercing and experiment with
using a leather muzzle and/or harness on the bear. No Kalandar was willing
to accept that a bear could be controlled without a nose rope. They were
however willing to learn the names of medicines that would lessen the
infections |
||
Removal of the Canine teeth: The cub has small black
canines as part of its milk teeth and it is between the 8th and 10th month
that the adult canines appear and are removed. This is done with no anesthesia
and again an iron rod is hammered in, with a blunt wooden pestle, and
the tooth dislodged with force. The use of a pliers - like instrument,
resembling kitchen tongs made of iron, is sometimes used. The Kalandars
deny any injuries take place to the sensitive muzzle of the sloth bear
or that the long lips are torn or injured, during this process. The cubs
(17) and juveniles (7) examined by us while administering questionnaires,
either still had their milk canines or had already had them removed so
that only the cavity left behind in the mouth could be observed. We have
not been able to witness a canine removal first hand but have examined
the cubs soon after the canines have been knocked out and the distress
and physical trauma to the cub was apparent. The teeth are used for talismans
and amulets and command a good price. However the Kalandar claims he removes
them for the safety of his family, the public, and the crowds that gather
around the dancing bear and not for its monetary value. However the investigators
noted several juveniles with their canines intact. These were to be removed
later when the teeth were larger and had more value as amulets; thereby
being a more painful experience for the animals |
||
Trimming of Claws: By and large the cutting of the claws takes
place twice a year during Diwali and during Holi; or during spring and
autumn so to say, according to the Kalandars. However it was observed
that only 20% of the bears had one or two claws removed at the very base.
Pulling out of claws is not a practice among the Kalandars and the investigators
did not come across any case of claws being pulled out. However among
the claws on sale some showed bone and a large part of the phalange attached.
According to the Kalandars these were removed from a dead Sloth bear,
by an owner who was desperate for money or had a family crisis to handle
as once again violating the body of the dead bear was against their “religion.”
In case of a good enough price paid by a client who urgently needs the
claw as a talisman or by foreign buyers who pay well, the Kalandar supplies
it without qualms, out of season. The claws are cut using brass or iron
Sarotas (betel nut crackers) . At several of the villages when the owner
and trainer or other bear owners |
||
surrounded
the bear to demonstrate a point to the investigators, the unrest and fear
of the animal was very evident. The Kalandars explained the bears fear
the group is going to cut its nails or change its nose rope both of which
were obviously traumatic memories for the adult bear. Although safety
was quoted as the reason for clipping the nails, and the comfort of the
bear while walking on the paved roads was the second reason given for
trimming its claws, profit was certainly the strongest incentive, as bear
claws were in great demand by the bear audiences, whether rural, urban,
or foreign. Hence the Kalandars trim the claws seasonally and do not remove
them (by pulling out) as they provide recurring income |
||
Diseases
and Treatment: According to the Kalandar the cub or juvenile
bear suffers no illness beyond a form of epileptic fits which attack it
before the age of three years. Should the bear survive beyond this age
it usually lives out its normal life span till thirty years. However as
said earlier, our questionnaires elicited the information that the oldest
bears were approximately 15-16 years of age and only 10% reached this
age. However wildlife field workers conjecture the cause of death in the
bears is often respiratory congestion, and two cases of post-mortem conducted
in Karnataka, Bangalore, by Mr Srinath of the WWF revealed tuberculosis
as the cause of death. However no documentation has been done in this
area nor have any scientific studies been undertaken on this subject.
Only 10% of the Kalandars questioned had visited a veterinary doctor to
consult about an illness of their bear; almost unanimously they preferred
to go to a village elder for treatment. This “epileptic fit”
is characterised by the bear becoming dull and listless for a few days;
his face swells up and he refuses food; then suddenly he convulses and
falls down usually to never recover. The Kalandars are very fatalistic
about this illness. Zoo authorities hazarded a diagnosis: acute worm infection
followed by a cardiac arrest. The investigators did not see any animal
with these symptoms. A request has been made to bring the bear in for
a post-mortem should any such death take place in the villages visited.
However the investigators did see two adult bears that were very sick
and after showing symptoms of respiratory congestion they passed away.
Three cubs handled by the investigators died of severe gastro-enteric
symptoms. We were told a large number of cubs, almost 60 70% of those
purchased died of similar symptoms. We conclude poor unhygienic feeding
after acquiring the cubs is responsible for this high mortality rate.
Respiratory and intestinal infections seem to be responsible for most
of the deaths |
||
Mortality
Rates: The questionnaire revealed that the cubs have a high mortality
rate at the market itself; approximately two cubs out of ten succumb to
the shock of separation from the mother and simply “fade”
away according to the Kalandars. The Kalandar trader or middleman whohandles
the purchasing for their fellow Kalandars reports that the initial trauma
of the capture tended to increase the death rate but could not hazard
the percentage of cub deaths. Should the cubs survive, transportation
takes its toll as the cubs are carried long distances in gunny sacking;
or put into fruit baskets covered with leaves / fruits; or packed with
hay in crates. The preferred mode of transport is trucks which obligingly
carry the Kalandars through the length of this country. Today travelling
by train has become a hazard the Kalandars claim, as the authorities and
fellow passengers often object or ask too many questions should they recognize
the animal. Again transportation entails a twenty to forty percent loss
in cubs. Should the cub reach the village and its owner safely, the first
fifteen days are critical as it must accept the Kalandar owner and begin
eating. The Kalandars conjecture 1-2 cubs out of 15-20 brought to a village
each season die at this stage of handling. In the second year of the study
the investigators had an opportunity to countercheck these statistics.
In BV7 and BV8, 21 cubs were received. Over a period of three months the
investigators observed three deaths of cubs due to respiratory and intestinal
disorders. At the end of this three month period when the cubs were approximately
five months old, the investigators found only five cubs continued to be
with the Kalandars in these two villages. The investigators were told
the cubs had all “died”. This either leaves us staring at
an extremely low survival rate close to only 24 % as in this particular
case or the cubs had been sold through a route as yet not known to the
investigators. Although the Kalandars almost uniformly insisted their
training methods produce no trauma with consequent fatalities, they do
agree that the percentage of bears lost in the first year can be as high
as 40%, with improved chances of the bear cub surviving as it becomes
a juvenile. If the bear survives its third year without succumbing to
“epileptic fits” the Kalandar feels it usually lives on for
15-20 years more. It is estimated from the Kalandar questionnaires then,
that on an average the larger villages (BV7, BV8, BV15, BV 21, BV24, )
receive at least 15-20 cubs each season and these are distributed to the
smaller Kalandar settlements. A settlement as large as BV13 could receive
up to 25 - 30 bear cubs in a season. In Karnataka on an average 9 -11
cubs are needed to replace those lost each year among the 63 families
licensed to dance bears, (Srinath, WWF). In this small sampling of Kalandar
settlements, it is estimated that approximately 115 cubs reach the 36
villages each season. Of these in the first six months over fifty percent
are lost to disease, trauma and poor feeding. Since there is no valid
licensing system at present in India, and since no statistics are available
of poached bears / cubs with the wildlife functionaries, the estimated
population of dancing bears is being conservatively calculated from the
administration of the Survey Questionnaire given to the Kalandar. It must
be noted that the present sub-group examined in North India and in |
||
Karnataka has indicated that almost as many more Kalandar settlements
exist through the States of Orissa, Bihar, Gujarat, Maharashtra, Tamilnadu
and Punjab. This significantly increases the number of captured cubs per
season.
|
||
|
©WILDLIFE SOS - INDIA |
||